By Melane Sampson

Therapists and other healthcare professionals often work in settings where they may be alone with patients, make home visits or conduct sessions outside traditional clinical environments. Yet, despite the potential for workplace violence, safety protocols and readily accessible emergency-response tools may not always be in place.
Kara Smith, LCMFT, owner of Maryland Marriage & Family Therapy Centers, has experienced these risks firsthand during more than two decades working across clinical settings, including homeless shelters, substance-use disorder programs, private practices, and correctional facilities. After experiencing situations in which she feared for her safety and had to call 911, Ms. Smith introduced wearable safety technology into her own practice and later expanded its use to her clinical team. She now partners with closely held Silent Beacon to raise awareness of the safety challenges facing therapists and other healthcare professionals.
In an interview with BioTuesdays, Ms. Smith and Silent Beacon Enterprise Safety Expert Tyler Charuhas discuss the risks clinicians and healthcare professionals face, the limitations of conventional workplace-safety measures, and how wearable technology can provide an additional way to summon help when a situation escalates.
You have spent more than 20 years working in a range of clinical settings, including homeless shelters, substance-use disorder programs and private practices. What have you observed about the safety risks therapists face, and how have those risks changed over the course of your career?

Ms. Smith: I want to clarify that people who are seeking mental health treatment are not dangerous in general. Ninety-nine percent of the people we work with are there simply to get help. Having said that, there are situations in which a patient is severely mentally ill, angry or feels trapped, and there is potential for the healthcare professional’s safety to be at risk. We need to prepare and be ready for those situations when and if they occur.
The risks can vary. In general, the therapist is sitting in a closed room with the patient, and there are risks associated with not having immediate help. There are also a lot of healthcare providers going into people’s homes, whether in a hospital setting or a substance-use treatment setting. Earlier in my career, I worked in incarceration settings, and in all of these instances, we are alone.
That has not changed over the years. We are still going into these environments largely alone to help people, and I think there is a real lack of awareness about how to protect healthcare providers in these settings, given the statistics around workplace violence.
Can you describe one or two situations in your career when you genuinely feared for your safety and had to call 911 or otherwise seek emergency assistance? What did those experiences make you realize about the lack of safety infrastructure available to therapists?
Ms. Smith: Safety is taken for granted in a lot of these settings. As a young clinician, I was put into a lot of situations where my safety was at risk. I had no direction, no protocol—and this was before cellphones were widely used.
When I worked for a county substance-use disorder agency right out of graduate school, I was tasked with going into jails and conducting assessments of incarcerated people. I was placed in a small room behind a closed door with one person, and I had no awareness of what to do if something dangerous happened. I had no way to help myself if he had jumped across the table at me. It was a good example of a lack of protocol or any safety plan. As a young clinician, I don’t believe it was my responsibility to know what that plan should be. Someone higher up in the chain of command should have been developing a safety protocol for clinicians.
There were multiple times when I remember being really scared while working in homeless services. Most of the people there were just trying to get by and take advantage of what was being offered to them, but some were severely mentally ill. If we didn’t hear from them or see them, we would have to go into their apartments to do a wellness check, and I did these by myself. I remember being scared and not understanding that there should be a safety protocol in place. I did have to call 911 occasionally.
I’ve been very lucky because I haven’t been attacked personally, but those things do happen to therapists all the time. Every year, we hear about a psychiatrist or therapist being killed.
Therapy is often viewed as a relatively low-risk healthcare profession. Why is that perception misleading? What characteristics of one-on-one and group therapy can create unique safety risks for clinicians?
Ms. Smith: We often picture the therapist sitting in a chair and the patient on the couch having these deep, meaningful conversations, but the reality is that we have a wide range of needs coming into our office, and often we don’t know what their situation is.
They may come into the office for their first appointment and you’re meeting with them after hours. Sometimes we’re the only person working in the building. It’s dark outside, and we’re alone locking up. I work with a lot of couples, and it can get intense. I’ve had people get very angry at me or their spouse, stand up screaming or walk out and slam the door. There’s a lot of room for escalation in the private-practice arena.
A lot of clinics don’t have the money for security. There’s no button you can press that calls the security person down the hall, as there might be in a hospital. Isolation is the unique safety risk for one-on-one and group therapy. That’s why I’m working with Silent Beacon—to try to bring some attention to these gaps in safety.
How common are threats, intimidation or potentially violent incidents in your experience, and what do you believe the broader mental-health profession may be underestimating about workplace violence against therapists and other behavioral-health practitioners?
Ms. Smith: I’ve put a lot of thought into why safety has been overlooked. You look at the statistics and think, wow, that’s pretty remarkable. But I think it’s because of the isolation, and also because we’re not collaborating with other therapists and talking about the things we’re doing and what’s happening in our day to day that might set off alarm bells for the industry.
We’re all in the business of helping people. We’re taught to validate, listen and see the good, but there is also a bit of a barrier in that we have people who can come into our office and potentially cause harm to us. I’m trying to rip the blinders off so we can have a good look at what we need to protect our teams.
What are the practical limitations of relying on a cellphone, office staff or traditional security measures when a therapist is alone with a patient and a situation begins to escalate?
Ms. Smith: It’s the time it takes to access your phone. We’re not looking at our phones during sessions. It could be next to us, but usually it’s not necessarily near us. Even if you’re able to grab your phone, you still have to unlock it, get to the phone icon and dial 911. There are multiple steps, and that time is really essential. Not to mention we’re likely scared in that moment. Silent Beacon is a fast, one-step way to connect.

From Silent Beacon’s perspective, what is the specific safety gap that wearable technology is designed to address for healthcare and behavioral-health professionals? Why can the ability to summon help without reaching for or unlocking a phone be particularly important in an escalating situation?
Mr. Charuhas: We’ve seen a lot of technology already implemented, including panic buttons installed under desks. I’ve worked with companies where people have been in situations in which they were unable to press the button because they had to navigate around a person who was behaving aggressively to get to it.
The safety gap we’re trying to fill is the ability to call for help while having that device on you at all times. Whether you’re in a session, walking to your car at night, conducting a visit or out in the community, you have the ability to call for help if you need it. It’s like having that button under the desk but being able to remove it and take it with you.
Being able to summon help without having to reach for your phone is very important. In a situation where someone is being aggressive, you’re going for your phone and trying to dial 911, there could be a misdial, you might have to close a couple of apps, or you might even pick up the wrong phone on the desk and not be able to unlock it.
The most important aspect of not having to touch your phone is the discreetness. It also takes the thinking out of it. You press and hold a button for about three seconds on a device discreetly worn on your wrist or on a lanyard, and it can make the phone call and send a mass text message within seconds. You don’t have to pick up your phone, which can make it obvious that you’re calling for help and potentially escalate the situation.
The watch is similar in size and look to an Apple Watch. When we set out to design the Silent Beacon wearables, we wanted them to look like something people are used to seeing. It just looks like a watch, so people don’t realize you’re wearing a security device.
We also have a lanyard version, which can be attached to the back of an identification badge, as well as a clothing clip version that can be attached to a collar or pocket. There are multiple ways to wear it depending on the situation.
Can you walk us through what happens technically when a therapist activates the Silent Beacon? How does the wearable communicate with the smartphone, and how are emergency calls, alerts and location information transmitted to the appropriate contacts?

Mr. Charuhas: When the person activates the panic button, they press and hold it for about three seconds. It will vibrate and blink, and we also have a silent mode. It immediately places a phone call to an emergency contact, which can be any number, such as 911 or a coworker.
That’s one of the biggest advantages of working with our company: We let you decide who it calls. Not every office needs a 911 notification. Some just need to connect with someone who can listen to what’s going on and provide extra help or help them navigate out of a difficult situation. There can be natural escalation patterns, and if you’re going into a situation where you might need to alert 911, you can change that contact number at any time.
The Silent Beacon itself has a microphone and speaker, so I can talk directly into the device and 911 or whoever is on the other end of the line can listen. In silent mode, I can mute the speaker so the person on the other end can listen in without the user hearing the call.
That’s a big advantage with our product. Under-the-desk buttons are great—I would never discourage using them—but in that case, 911 has no idea what they’re responding to. They could under- or over-deploy in these situations. With our system, they can listen to what is actually happening. The 911 operator can hear if the situation is escalating and determine how to dispatch first responders.
While I’m on the phone with 911 or a coworker, a mass text message, push notification and email are sent to as many people as you like. Our servers handle the text-message and email communication, while the phone controls the call.
The Silent Beacon communicates with the smartphone using Bluetooth. It operates within about 200 to 300 feet of the smartphone, so the phone can be in your pocket, left in a desk drawer or in a purse in another room. Once the panic button is triggered, it tells the phone to make the call and send the messages. The alerts and location information use the phone’s GPS.
Silent Beacon offers multiple alert modes, including emergency alerts and a silent mode. Why is it important for a workplace-safety system to offer different levels of response rather than treating every incident as an automatic 911 call?
Mr. Charuhas: Many of our extra features were suggested by customers, along with features we designed ourselves. We’ve incorporated what we’ve learned from people who have been using our product for years.
Silent mode, for example, is crucial when people want to be as discreet as possible while still giving the person on the receiving end the ability to listen in.
We also have two location-based features that don’t indicate you’re in an emergency. Footsteps mode is helpful for mental-healthcare professionals conducting walk-and-talk therapy, going into people’s homes or working out in the community. You can let your contacts know that you want to be tracked. You’re not in an emergency; you just want them to know your location.
If they call and you don’t answer, they can see your location and determine whether there might be an emergency. When you feel safe, you can turn the feature off and stop broadcasting your location.
Another feature is check-in. If you’re the last person to leave the office, conducting home visits or simply want management or another contact to know you’ve completed a visit and are safe, you can send a check-in. It’s a non-emergency message letting people know you’re safe and where you are at that moment. You can do that by tapping the button three times, without having to touch your phone. It provides that peace of mind.
For an organization considering this type of technology, what does implementation actually look like? How can an enterprise configure who receives an alert, establish response protocols and integrate the technology into an existing workplace-safety program?
Mr. Charuhas: Implementation is a big benefit of our technology and service. We can get anybody up and running in less than a week, as long as everyone is available for the training and development.
Because it’s a Bluetooth product, we ship the Silent Beacon directly to customers. We have two initial training calls. One is with the system administrator to help set up the dashboards, users and contacts. The second is with the people who will be wearing the devices.
From a therapist’s perspective, it’s as easy as downloading an app, pressing connect and charging the device once a month. From the administrator’s side, the primary responsibility is the initial setup. You can set it up once and, depending on your needs, essentially leave it alone. It is customizable to each organization’s needs.
Each Silent Beacon can be programmed to call or text its own unique number and email its own unique group of people. I have organizations with 100 devices where each one is set to call a different person or group. Alternatively, all of the Silent Beacons can contact the same people.
Updates are sent immediately to the user’s phone. If an administrator changes a contact, the user receives a notification letting them know, for example, that their dispatcher has been changed from their manager to 911.
In terms of integrating the Silent Beacon into existing workplace-safety programs, I’ve seen organizations incorporate the panic button into their regular safety drills. They change the number to call from 911 to a local number and practice using the Silent Beacon. We recommend practicing regularly so people are confident about which buttons to press in an emergency.
The company works with organizations that have employees operating alone or in unpredictable environments. What have you learned from other industries about the broader problem of response time, and how does the behavioral-health environment differ from settings such as home healthcare, social services or field work?
Mr. Charuhas: As I’ve implemented our solution in different organizations, I’ve noticed that they all have very similar needs, although the reasons for those needs are different. One organization may have one person working alone at certain times, while another may be a hospital with hundreds of people working at any one time.
The events that trigger the need to call for help may be different, but what the system needs to do is relatively the same: call someone or text others that help is needed.
I’ve learned that when it comes to response time, it needs to be quick. The Silent Beacon takes the risk out of accessing your phone and dialing a number. When an aggressive situation is happening, by the time you get to your phone and open the screen, there can be so much chaos and adrenaline that you might dial the wrong number and have to redial.
With our panic button, there is no lapse in time. You press the button, it takes the thinking out of it and, most importantly, you’re hands-free so you can protect yourself if need be.
What prompted you to introduce a wearable safety system into your own practice, and what did you learn after expanding it to the therapists on your team? Did having a reliable way to summon help change how your clinicians approached patient sessions or their overall sense of security?
Ms. Smith: When I started my business and began hiring therapists to work for me, I felt a sense of responsibility for them. A lot of them are newer therapists, while others are more experienced. They’re in a building that I lease, and I know they may be leaving the building by themselves. I wanted them to have a sense of security and feel safe when they’re working.
For me, it’s peace of mind knowing they have a way to protect themselves if need be. Our job is to help other people’s nervous systems feel safer. This helps the therapists’ nervous systems feel safer so they can be there for their clients.
The burnout rate in our field is really high. We’re dealing with a lot of emotions and volatility and emotional pain every day, so if there is one thing we can do to help therapists keep doing their jobs in a way that allows them to take deep breaths and go into it every day without that fear, that’s a real comfort to me. It’s about self-care, and I hope other facilities see it as a way to address the burnout we face in our industry.
I’m always surprised that facilities much larger than mine don’t have anything in place to keep their therapists safe. Perhaps they feel they don’t have the budget for safety protocols, but Silent Beacon is not an expensive intervention.
Mr. Charuhas: When talking with people who are getting comparison quotes, because it is a Bluetooth-connected device, there aren’t a lot of infrastructure changes required. We don’t have to do big installations, replace wiring or update Wi-Fi or access points that can be expensive. The only requirement is that employees carry smartphones with Bluetooth capability.
Many of our customers have openly stated that Silent Beacon is more affordable compared with other safety options. As a general example, an organization with 10 therapists would be in the range of $1,500 to $2,000 per year, or roughly $160 a month. We aim to keep the cost as affordable as possible while continuing to invest in research and development.
From a practice-owner perspective, how can clinician safety affect the broader healthcare operation—including recruitment and retention, staff morale, patient care, liability and the willingness of clinicians to work with higher-risk patient populations?
Ms. Smith: I’ve had very little staff turnover because I want to run my business in a way that makes people feel cared for, seen, adequately protected and appreciated. I see the Silent Beacon as an employee benefit. It’s theirs—they can take it home and use it when they need it.
Mr. Charuhas: I’ve had customers tell me they encourage their employees to use it in their personal lives outside of work because emergencies happen at any time, whether you’re heading to a football game with family or in the parking lot of a grocery store and need to call 911. It’s your device; use it in your everyday life so you feel safe.
Silent Beacon is also available directly to consumers. We started as a company supplying individual devices to people who wanted an easy-to-use way to feel safer, and then branched out to serving organizations and facilities, from small healthcare clinics to large hospitals, as well as other industries such as real estate and retail.
As healthcare organizations increasingly look at workplace violence as a workforce and patient-care issue, where do you see wearable safety technology fitting within a comprehensive safety strategy? What should it complement rather than replace?
Mr. Charuhas: A lot of people have spent years laying the framework for safe environments with things such as cameras and wired panic-button devices. But organizations are realizing that there can be gaps when therapists are seeing patients in the home or out in the community.
Our device is like giving that direct-to-911 panic button under the desk to every therapist who has to leave the clinic and see people in their homes or conduct walk-and-talk therapy. Silent Beacon can complement an organization’s existing safety infrastructure or serve as a standalone solution.
It’s also more than a one-way communication. With our system, the person receiving the alert can communicate with the person who pressed the panic button. In silent mode, 911 dispatchers can listen to what’s happening and determine what level of escalation is occurring and what kind of response the situation requires.
You are now formally partnering with Silent Beacon to raise awareness about therapist safety. If you could change one thing about how healthcare organizations, policymakers and the public think about the safety of therapists and other behavioral-health professionals, what would it be?
Ms. Smith: I want people to know and understand that there should be a protocol in place and that it doesn’t have to break the bank. You can add this to your budget every year, but the benefit outweighs the cost tenfold. Just the peace of mind that it gives you and your staff and team going into potentially dangerous situations is significant.
Mental-health services need to have a safety protocol in place, and they tend to be nonexistent. One piece of advice I was given years ago was, “Put your chair closer to the door than your client’s so if something happens you can get out faster.” That’s great advice, but there has to be something more comprehensive and thoughtful in place for healthcare professionals so that we have a way to feel safe when we go to work every day.
• • • •
To connect with Silent Beacon or any other companies featured on BioTuesdays, send us an email at editor@biotuesdays.com.






